Who Actually Had the Load
Most of what an insurance claims investigator does on a cargo loss is fix the sequence. A full trailer driven out of a yard, a few pallets lifted at a fuel stop and a load handed to a carrier that only borrowed a real name are three different losses. They start in different places and leave different records.
The sequence also decides where the claim goes next. Under the Carmack Amendment, the carrier that issued the bill of lading and the carrier that delivered are liable for the actual loss, whether it was caused by the receiving carrier, the delivering carrier or another carrier over whose line or route the property moved (49 U.S.C. 14706(a)(1)). When a load was double brokered, the truck at the dock may not belong to the carrier on the rate confirmation, and the file has to show which company held the freight at each point.
We walk the load from the booking forward: the tender, the rate confirmation, the calls and emails, the driver, the tractor and trailer numbers, the gate. Where the trail turns into a fictitious pickup, we say so, and we say how we know.
A request from an adjuster might start like this: a load of electronics left a shipper's dock in Dallas, the carrier on the rate confirmation says it never sent a truck, and the broker's emails show the carrier's phone number changed the day before pickup.
A Claim That Does Not Add Up
Some losses come with a detail that sits wrong. The seal number on the delivery receipt does not match the bill of lading. The driver's phone went quiet an hour before the reported theft. The declared value is higher than the shipper's invoice.
Texas treats part of this as its own offense. Penal Code Sec. 31.18 reaches a driver lawfully contracted to carry a specific cargo who, intending to help receive, hide, store, sell or dispose of stolen cargo, fails to deliver the whole load or causes the seal to be broken on the vehicle or the container. Separately, Insurance Code Sec. 701.051 requires a written report to the insurance fraud unit of the Texas Department of Insurance no later than the 30th day after a person determines or reasonably suspects that a fraudulent insurance act has been or is about to be committed.
Whether a claim is fraud is a decision for you and your counsel. Our part is the facts under it. We interview the people in the sequence, pull the records that can be checked, and write what we saw apart from what we think, so the referral, the denial or the payment rests on a record a reviewer can follow.
The Freight Is Still Somewhere
Freight that has been taken still has to be parked, stored or sold. If the unit had tracking, the last reported position is where we start. If it did not, we work the routine of whoever moved it and the people who would have seen it arrive.
We locate and document. We do not tow, and we do not approach a stolen unit. When we have a location, it goes to law enforcement or a licensed recovery partner with our findings attached, and to you.
A claim against the carrier runs on its own clock. Federal law does not let a carrier allow less than 9 months to file a claim, or less than 2 years to sue from the date it gives written notice that it has disallowed any part of the claim (49 U.S.C. 14706(e)(1)). Once a written claim is received, the carrier has 30 days to acknowledge it, unless it has paid or declined it in writing by then, and 120 days to pay, decline or make a firm settlement offer. If it cannot do that in 120 days, it must tell the claimant in writing where the claim stands and why, then again every 60 days while the claim is pending (49 CFR 370.5 and 370.9). Counsel decides what those dates mean for your file.
How an Engagement Runs
Intake
Gil Leon reads the request himself. Tell us the claim number, the insured, the loss date and what the file needs from us: the sequence, a location, a person, or all three.
Records
Bill of lading, rate confirmation, tender emails, gate and yard logs, telematics history and the police report. We check what can be checked and note what cannot.
The Field
The yard, the dock, the route and the people on it: dispatchers, drivers, yard staff and the receiver. Each interview is written up with the time, the place and who was in the room.
The Report
What happened in order, who touched the load, where it is if we found it, and the gaps we could not close. Written for an examiner or a reviewer who opens the file a year from now.
What an Insurance Claims Investigator Needs First
- The claim number, the insured, and the adjuster or examiner who owns the file.
- The bill of lading, the rate confirmation and any tender or booking emails.
- Tractor, trailer and container numbers, plates, VINs and seal numbers.
- The police report number and the agency that took it.
- Telematics or ELD history for the unit, if the carrier has released it.
- The shipper's invoice or other proof of the value claimed.
- Names and numbers for the driver, the dispatcher and anyone at the pickup or the delivery.
Sources
Facts about laws, agencies and places on this page come from the sources below. Nothing on this page is legal advice.
- U.S. Code, 49 U.S.C. 14706, Liability of carriers under receipts and bills of ladinglaw.cornell.edu
- Code of Federal Regulations, 49 CFR 370.5, Acknowledgment of claimslaw.cornell.edu
- Code of Federal Regulations, 49 CFR 370.9, Disposition of claimslaw.cornell.edu
- Texas Penal Code, Sec. 31.18, Cargo theftstatutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Texas Insurance Code, Sec. 701.051, Duty to reportstatutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Texas Occupations Code, Chapter 1702, Secs. 1702.101, 1702.104 and 1702.324statutes.capitol.texas.gov