Houston, Texas

Texas and nationwide

Request Recovery

Glossary

The CarmackAmendment

The Carmack Amendment is the federal law that makes a carrier liable for the actual loss of or damage to freight it moves in interstate commerce. For motor carriers and freight forwarders it is 49 U.S.C. 14706, which also sets the shortest time a carrier may give you to file a claim and to sue.

What the Carmack Amendment Says

The Carmack Amendment puts lost or damaged interstate freight on the carrier's account. A carrier that takes property for transportation must issue a receipt or bill of lading, and it is liable to the person entitled to recover under that document for the actual loss or injury to the property.

Liability reaches past the carrier that loaded the trailer. The receiving carrier, the delivering carrier and any carrier over whose line or route the freight moved are all covered, including a move into an adjacent foreign country, such as a load crossing into Mexico, when it travels under a through bill of lading. Under section 14706(b), the carrier that issued the receipt or the delivering carrier, once it has paid, can recover that amount from the carrier over whose line or route the loss happened.

The original statute dates from 1906. In a 2010 opinion, the Supreme Court described its purpose in plain terms: a cargo owner should not have to search out which of several carriers was at fault before getting paid.

Two details catch people out. A carrier that never issued a bill of lading is still liable. And under section 14706(c), a carrier can set rates that limit its liability to a value the shipper declared or agreed to in writing, if that value is reasonable. The limit lives in the paperwork, so read it before the load moves.

What Counts as a Claim

The claims rules are in 49 CFR Part 370, which applies to motor carriers and freight forwarders handling property in interstate or foreign commerce. Under section 370.3, a claim is a written communication filed with the proper carrier inside the time limit in the bill of lading or the contract. It has to identify the shipment, assert that the carrier is liable for the loss or damage, and ask for a specified or determinable amount of money.

A phone call to dispatch is not a written claim. An email that reports the loss but names no amount leaves out one of the elements.

The Dates That Run

  • Filing the claim: a carrier may not allow less than 9 months, by rule, contract or otherwise. The bill of lading or contract sets the actual period, and it can be longer.
  • Acknowledgment: the carrier must acknowledge a written claim within 30 days of receiving it, unless it has already paid or declined the claim in writing in that time (49 CFR 370.5).
  • Decision: within 120 days the carrier must pay, decline or make a firm compromise offer in writing. If it cannot, it must tell the claimant in writing where the claim stands and why, and repeat that notice every 60 days while the claim is open (49 CFR 370.9).
  • Lawsuit: a carrier may not allow less than 2 years to sue, counted from the date it gives written notice that it has disallowed any part of the claim (49 U.S.C. 14706(e)).

Where It Meets a Theft Case

When a load is stolen, the claim and the investigation need the same thing: a sequence. Who signed for the freight, which carrier held it at each point, the seal number and where it was applied, and the last time anyone saw the trailer with that seal intact. The claim rests on that paper, and so does any argument about it.

The hard cases are the ones where the freight was handed to someone posing as the carrier, a fictitious pickup. Who answers for that loss depends on the facts and the contracts, and that is a question for counsel. What counsel needs from us is the order of events from the booking forward, with times, places and names in full and the gaps marked. That is the core of cargo theft and fraud investigation.

When a Load Is Lost

  1. Read the Paperwork

    Pull the bill of lading and the contract. Find the claim period, any declared value and any limit on liability.

  2. Report It

    Call it in to the police, get the report number, and write down when and where the unit was last seen.

  3. File in Writing

    Send the carrier a written claim that identifies the shipment, says the carrier is liable and names an amount. Keep proof of the date.

  4. Preserve the Record

    Keep the delivery receipt, seal numbers, gate logs, photographs, and every call and message with the time.

  5. Mark the Dates

    Calendar the 30-day, 120-day and 60-day marks and the 2-year suit period. Talk to counsel before accepting a compromise.

Sources

Facts about laws, agencies and places on this page come from the sources below. Nothing on this page is legal advice.

  1. 49 U.S.C. 14706, Liability of carriers under receipts and bills of lading (Cornell LII)law.cornell.edu
  2. 49 CFR 370.1, Applicability of regulations (Cornell LII)law.cornell.edu
  3. 49 CFR 370.3, Filing of claims (Cornell LII)law.cornell.edu
  4. 49 CFR 370.5, Acknowledgment of claims (Cornell LII)law.cornell.edu
  5. 49 CFR 370.9, Disposition of claims (Cornell LII)law.cornell.edu
  6. Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha Ltd. v. Regal-Beloit Corp., U.S. Supreme Court, 2010 (Cornell LII)law.cornell.edu
  7. 49 U.S.C. 13906, Security of motor carriers, brokers, and freight forwarders (Cornell LII)law.cornell.edu

When the Claim Follows a Theft

CommonQuestions

  1. Section 14706 is written about carriers and freight forwarders. Whether a broker answers for a particular loss turns on what it actually did and what its contracts say, so take that question to counsel. A broker's BMC-84 bond is a separate matter, tied by statute to unpaid freight charges.

  2. Section 14706(d) allows a civil action in a United States district court or in a state court, and it sets rules on which carrier can be sued where. Where to file is a decision for counsel.

Tell UsWhat You Know.

Send the facts you have. Gil reads every request himself.

Request Recovery