A Defendant Who Cannot Be Served
The return of service comes back unserved. The defendant moved, the apartment has a new tenant, and the phone number in the file now rings at somebody else's house. That is where a legal private investigator starts.
In federal court the clock is short. Rule 4(m) gives 90 days after the complaint is filed. After that the court must dismiss the action without prejudice against that defendant or order service within a set time, and if the plaintiff shows good cause for the failure, the court must extend the time. Rule 4(e)(2)(B) allows papers to be left at the individual's dwelling or usual place of abode with someone of suitable age and discretion who lives there, which puts weight on whether the address really is that person's home.
We start with the background: family, work history, the vehicle, the habits. Then the records, then the routine. Before we report an address we confirm identity, and the report says when the subject was seen there, how often, and what confirmed it.
A Witness Who Has Moved On
In a trucking or cargo case, the person who saw what happened may be a driver, a dispatcher or a yard hand who has changed jobs twice since.
Where that person lives and works now matters for more than a phone call. A federal subpoena can command a person to attend a trial, hearing or deposition within 100 miles of where the person resides, is employed or regularly transacts business in person (Rule 45(c)(1)(A)).
We find the witness, confirm identity and report the location to counsel. If the witness has a lawyer, or might, tell us before we start. Texas Disciplinary Rule 4.02(a) bars a lawyer representing a client from communicating, or causing or encouraging another to communicate, about the subject of the representation with a person the lawyer knows is represented by another lawyer on that subject, unless the other lawyer consents or the law authorizes it. We make no contact until counsel says who we may speak to.
A request from a firm in Fort Worth might start like this: a former dispatcher is the only person who heard the pickup change by phone, and the last address in the file is a duplex that has since been rented to someone else.
Equipment at the Center of the Suit
Some cases are about a thing: a tractor, a trailer, a loader, or a set of units on a lease that stopped paying. Texas makes a writ of sequestration available to a plaintiff in a suit for title or possession of personal property, or to foreclose or enforce a mortgage, lien or security interest on it, when a reasonable conclusion may be drawn that there is immediate danger the party holding it will conceal, dispose of, ill-treat, waste or destroy it, or remove it from the county during the suit (Civil Practice and Remedies Code Sec. 62.001(1)).
A writ needs a place to go. Through our asset location work we find where the unit is and who controls it, record the VIN plate, the unit numbers and the yard, and give counsel a written account of how we found it. We do not take possession and we do not approach the unit. That runs through the court's process.
Working Under Counsel
An investigator a firm retains works inside the firm's obligations. Texas Disciplinary Rule 5.03 applies to a non-lawyer employed or retained by or associated with a lawyer, and its comment names investigators. A lawyer with direct supervisory authority has to make reasonable efforts to keep that person's conduct compatible with the lawyer's own professional obligations.
You set the scope and decide who we contact. The report names the source of each record and keeps what we saw apart from what we think. It goes to you, and nowhere else unless you send it on.
The private security chapter does not apply to an attorney while engaged in the practice of law (Occupations Code Sec. 1702.324(b)(9)). It does reach the hiring: contracting with a person who is required to hold a license under the chapter, knowing that person does not, is a Class A misdemeanor (Sec. 1702.386). Gil Leon is licensed by the Texas Department of Public Safety, License No. 180651701, and the Department's Texas Online Private Security site has a Search Licensees page for checking a license holder.
How a Legal Private Investigator Works a Request
The Request
Gil Leon reads it himself. Send the matter as far as you can share it: who you need, why, and the deadline that governs it.
Background and Records
Where the person has lived and worked, who they are close to, what they drive, and what is on file in their name.
Eyes On
We go where the records point and sit on the address if that is what it takes. Identity is confirmed before anything is reported.
The Report
Addresses, dates and times in full, how each was confirmed, and what we could not confirm. Written so a colleague who joins the case next year can follow it.
What to Send With the Request
- The person's full name, any other names used, and a date of birth if you have one.
- Every address, phone number and email in the file, with the date each was last good.
- The court and cause number, and any service deadline or setting that governs the work.
- Returns of service and notes from earlier attempts.
- Employers, vehicles and relatives named in pleadings, discovery or the client's records.
- Whether the person has counsel, or may.
- For equipment: VINs, serial and unit numbers, the lease or security agreement, and the last known yard.
Sources
Facts about laws, agencies and places on this page come from the sources below. Nothing on this page is legal advice.
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 4, Summonslaw.cornell.edu
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 45, Subpoenalaw.cornell.edu
- Texas Disciplinary Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 4.02, Communication with one represented by counsel (Texas Center for Legal Ethics)legalethicstexas.com
- Texas Disciplinary Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 5.03, Responsibilities regarding nonlawyer assistants (Texas Center for Legal Ethics)legalethicstexas.com
- Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code, Sec. 62.001, Grounds for a writ of sequestrationstatutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Texas Occupations Code, Chapter 1702, Secs. 1702.324 and 1702.386statutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Texas Online Private Security (TOPS), Search Licenseestops.portal.texas.gov